The first time, Ananya was twelve and the pen had rolled under the bus seat.
A boy in a blue school uniform picked it up without being asked.
"It's leaking," he said, handing it back anyway, ink smudged across his fingers.
She never learned his name.
The bus reached her stop before she could ask.
The second time, she was twenty two, waiting out the rain under the Churchgate overbridge.
Someone's umbrella tipped sideways and a gust flipped it inside out.
"Here," a voice said, folding half the umbrella over her shoulder instead of his own.
Ananya looked up and something in her chest went very quiet.
He had ink stained fingers again, from a leaking pen in his shirt pocket.
"Do I know you," she asked, half laughing at herself.
"I don't think so," Rohan said, though he was already smiling like he did.
They talked until the rain stopped, then a little after.
He gave her his number on the back of a train ticket.
She lost the ticket somewhere between the overbridge and her building gate.
For six years neither of them tried very hard to explain the ache of it.
Ananya moved cities for work, came back for her sister's engagement.
Rohan took a transfer, came back for his cousin's wedding.
The two weddings, it turned out, were the same wedding.
His cousin was marrying her sister.
At the sangeet, the caterer sat them at the same round table by accident of alphabet.
Ananya saw the ink stain first, old and faint, a shadow on his third finger that never fully washed out.
"You still use that pen," she said, before she'd even said hello.
Rohan went very still.
"You're the umbrella girl," he said, and then, quieter, "you're the bus girl too, aren't you."
Neither of them could explain how they knew, only that they did, the way you recognise a song from two notes.
"Twelve years," Ananya said, counting on her fingers.
"Three times."
"I kept thinking I was imagining it," Rohan admitted.
"Every time I saw ink on someone's hand I'd look up like an idiot."
Her mother, passing with a tray of mithai, paused at their table.
"You two look like you've met before," she said, not knowing how true it was.
Ananya caught Rohan's eye and neither of them laughed, though they wanted to.
"Something like that," Rohan said.
Outside, the wedding lights swung gently in the breeze, the same breeze that once flipped an umbrella inside out.
Ananya thought of the pen rolling under a bus seat, of a ticket lost to wind, of a sister marrying a cousin neither of them had planned on.
Some things, she decided, didn't need to be chased.
They only needed enough years to catch up.